Skip to content
ScrollSure

What disappointed buyers?

Main issue: Authenticity and tampering doubts, in 2 of 17 detailed low-star reviews.

19 of 100 TikTok reviews are 1–2 stars (19%)

Feb 16, 2025 – Oct 7, 2026 · 1★ 17 · 2★ 2 · all low-star reviews we found

Top complaint reasons

  • 6 Jars arriving open, leaking or underfilled
  • 3 Missing or undelivered orders
  • 2 Authenticity and tampering doubts

Counts show reviews mentioning each reason. One review can mention several reasons.

Authenticity and tampering doubts

Other concerns

2 of 17 detailed low-star reviews · 12%

Mostly strong complaints

Some cited buyers question whether the item is genuine or previously opened, pointing to removed stickers, ripped boxes and a fingerprint in the product.

Read 2 example reviews
  • “It looks like some stickers were removed from the bottom of the box.”
    TikTok Shop review · 1★ · 2026-07-25
  • “seal lifted enough to see a fingerprint in the product”
    TikTok Shop review · 1★ · 2025-05-30

Skin irritation and breakouts

Product performance

2 of 17 detailed low-star reviews · 12%

Mostly strong complaints

A few cited buyers describe breakouts or a severe reaction after use; these are individual experiences, not evidence about every item.

Read 2 example reviews
  • “I had a severe allergic reaction after using this product and ended up in the hospital.”
    TikTok Shop review · 1★ · 2026-04-18
  • “I used this for around a week and my forehead started getting filled with pimples”
    TikTok Shop review · 1★ · 2025-04-04

Unexpected scent or texture

Product performance

2 of 17 detailed low-star reviews · 12%

Mixed complaint severity

Some cited buyers found the smell or consistency unlike what they expected, describing a plastic or petroleum-like impression.

Read 2 example reviews
  • “The smell is like plastic. No hints of lavender, not even a beef smell.”
    TikTok Shop review · 1★ · 2026-03-20
  • “es una concistencia, rrara, que huele mas a petroleum”
    TikTok Shop review · 1★ · 2025-03-05

Hollow or uneven fill inside the jar

Product performance

1 of 17 detailed low-star reviews · 6%

Mixed complaint severity

Cited buyers describe discovering a hollow or gap in the balm after opening, which they saw as a sign of short measure.

Read 1 review excerpt
  • “cuando agarré sentí que se hundio”
    TikTok Shop review · 2★ · 2026-05-19
Read 19 low-star reviews
  • 1★

    The product arrived open; it doesn't look genuine. I do not recommend it. It looks like some stickers were removed from the bottom of the box.

    7/25/2026, 7:20:51 AM UTC

  • 1★

    Muy la la entrega ya son dos veces q lo pido no no lo dejan en el apartamento 204 necesito mi dinero lo pas pronto posible se extravío ya pregunte a las vecinos asi mi

    7/20/2026, 4:24:59 PM UTC

  • 2★

    Apenas la abrí hace unos días y mira lo que descubrí, un hueco que cabe mi dedo completo eso es un fraude porque solo uso de poquito y no se si vi a encontrar otro hueco que tristeza 😔😔😔y si es la original pero nunca me había pasada esto y me di cuenta porque cuando agarré sentí que se hundio

    5/19/2026, 8:26:00 AM UTC

  • 1★

    ⚠️ WARNING ⚠️ If you have sensitive skin or allergies. I had a severe allergic reaction after using this product and ended up in the hospital. Antihistamines didn’t work,and I needed medical treatment. This was a scary, and expensive experience. Please be careful and patch test.

    4/18/2026, 2:43:34 PM UTC

  • 1★

    Jar wasn't filled to the top, jar came in a brown box with paper stuffing, not the yellow box like all the others are coming in. The smell is like plastic. No hints of lavender, not even a beef smell. I'm not sure if I got a bad batch.

    3/20/2026, 6:29:06 PM UTC

  • 1★

    My product is not full it was open in little and the cream liking it’s look like liking in the box I need the new one please I am buyer before y no have problem with the first one please can you help me with this problem thank you

    9/24/2025, 2:27:16 AM UTC

  • 1★

    So um I didn't even get to use the product because it was completely caked with dead ants as soon as I took it out of the box. I know it's supposed to be all natural but this is disgusting!!!!!!!!!

    9/1/2025, 6:14:51 PM UTC

  • 1★

    Hoy lo recibí y viene toda la caja exterior derramada y al abrir el frasco el sello no estaba totalmente celado, y el frasco me llegó con la mitad del producto.

    8/17/2025, 7:47:13 PM UTC

  • 1★

    I received an open item. The aluminum seal was half open and the oil spilled inside. It was hot so it melted. Also, I don't know if the jar was supposed to be full or whoever had it before used it then returned it. I had to wait until it solidified to see how much was really in there.

    8/15/2025, 7:05:05 PM UTC

  • 1★

    Mi artículo jamás lo he recibido recibido y ya la tienda lo reporta como entregado y no me dejan poner la opción de artículo perdido , tengo ring cámara en la puerta principal si lo hubieran dejado cerca de la puerta principal o alrededor de la casa hubiéramos visto por cámara la persona con la entrega o el artículo y nunca fue asi , quiero mi reembolso o mi artículo por el k pagué por favor

    8/11/2025, 5:01:35 AM UTC

  • 2★

    Haven’t tried it yet but packaging inside was disappointing.

    8/9/2025, 6:10:16 PM UTC

  • 1★

    My product came somewhat empty. I was disappointed how they arrived.😒

    7/2/2025, 8:03:33 AM UTC

  • 1★

    I was SO excited to receive this today. I don’t know if it’s a knockoff, used product (clearly opened) or both. The box was ripped and sticker detached, seal lifted enough to see a fingerprint in the product. I’m beginning to think purchases on this app are a scam artist's delight. Throwing away $

    5/30/2025, 6:59:28 PM UTC

  • 1★

    😡😡😡 no me llegan los pedidos disen q los dejan en el buzón y no hay nada si quieren vengan a mirar cámaras pero dejen de robarsen la plata y la mercancía ya que no hacen el rembolso a la cuenta si no q te dicen vuelve a elegir el pedido u otro y x mas de q lo hago no llega nada

    4/27/2025, 10:02:12 PM UTC

  • 1★

    I usually have pretty clear skin so it’s easy for me to notice a difference when I use a different product on my skin. I started using this because I did have some minor bumps on my forehead. I used this for around a week and my forehead started getting filled with pimples :,(((

    4/4/2025, 2:15:03 AM UTC

  • 1★

    No contenta con el producto, es una concistencia, rrara, que huele mas a petroleum demasiado Blanco el color, lo aplico a mi piel, mi rostro y es como si fuera Vaseline lo que estoy aplicando.

    3/5/2025, 5:10:31 PM UTC

  • 1★

    This seller was advertising one day that was a sale instead of 2oz I will get 4oz so I was excited because I always wanted to order this cream, well today I get my order and my surprise was that the cream was only 2oz and is not having the cover when is new, so I’m very disappointed ☹️

    2/16/2025, 12:10:12 AM UTC

  • 1★

    No probado aún

    7/19/2025, 10:30:33 PM UTC

  • 1★

    They sent my package in poor condition—open and dirty. It is unacceptable to send something like that; the customer pays for what they buy, not to receive a product that is open and dirty.

    10/7/2026, 11:17:01 PM UTC

These reviews follow the platform’s recommended order. They do not establish a representative complaint rate or a change over time. Interpretations have not been independently verified.

Does it fit your needs?

Reviewers with dry skin describe using the balm for moisture, with mostly positive experiences and one report of drying.

Answer only what matters to you. You can skip this.

What skin concern are you addressing?

Reviews about dry skin (3)

  • Dry-skin users describe lasting moisture. (2 of 3 matching reviews)
  • One three-star reviewer felt it was drying and too expensive. (1 of 3 matching reviews)
  • “I get dry skin in the winter but this balm leaves it really moisturized.”

    TikTok Shop review · 5★ · 2025-03-16

  • “I noticed that it drying my face”

    TikTok Shop review · 3★ · 2025-09-30

Read all matching review excerpts
  • “I get dry skin in the winter but this balm leaves it really moisturized.”

    TikTok Shop review · 5★ · 2025-03-16

  • “it feeels really good hydrated which is good because I have dry skin”

    TikTok Shop review · 5★ · 2025-01-22

  • “I noticed that it drying my face”

    TikTok Shop review · 3★ · 2025-09-30

  • “I have dry skin and I have pscoriasis”

    TikTok Shop review · 5★ · 2025-01-22

  • “I want to believe it will work for my extra dry face”

    TikTok Shop review · 3★ · 2025-09-30

Not checked: suitability for your exact situation.

Your answers stay in this session and aren’t shared.

Options come from needs and contexts mentioned in 100 unique written reviews across ratings. Counts refer to matching comments, can overlap, and aren’t a measure of how well this will fit you.

What buyers consistently liked

Most praised: Hydrating without heaviness, in 4 of 71 sampled 5★ reviews.

From 71 sampled 5★ reviews on TikTok · Oct 29, 2026

Hydrating without heaviness

4 of 71

Cited buyers value that the balm moisturizes well while absorbing and not feeling greasy.

“The formula itself is incredibly hydrating without crossing into greasy territory. It absorbs fast”
Read 4 supporting reviews
  • “The formula itself is incredibly hydrating without crossing into greasy territory. It absorbs fast”

    TikTok Shop review · 5★ · 2026-08-05

  • “This soaks in completely leaving my combination skin looking even and glowy NOT GREASY!!”

    TikTok Shop review · 5★ · 2026-05-05

  • “Not too greasy, skin drank it up fast.”

    TikTok Shop review · 5★ · 2025-07-18

  • “I get dry skin in the winter but this balm leaves it really moisturized.”

    TikTok Shop review · 5★ · 2025-03-16

1 reviewer disagrees
  • “es como si fuera Vaseline lo que estoy aplicando”

    TikTok Shop review · 1★ · 2025-03-05

Read low-star reviews

Soft, smooth skin feel

4 of 71

Cited buyers describe skin feeling soft and smooth after applying.

“it made that arm and hand feel very soft. It’s not greasy.”
Read 4 supporting reviews
  • “it made that arm and hand feel very soft. It’s not greasy.”

    TikTok Shop review · 5★ · 2026-03-24

  • “I feel the skin very hydrated, shiny and smoother.”

    TikTok Shop review · 5★ · 2025-05-29

  • “Really moisturizing and it keeps ur face or eta really nice and smooth”

    TikTok Shop review · 5★ · 2025-01-03

  • “It leaves my skin feeling incredibly soft, smooth and moisturized”

    TikTok Shop review · 5★ · 2026-09-04

A little goes a long way

3 of 71

Cited buyers note that only a small amount is needed, so the jar lasts.

“Also a little goes along way so this will last me forever”
Read 3 supporting reviews
  • “Also a little goes along way so this will last me forever”

    TikTok Shop review · 5★ · 2025-11-13

  • “the jar is small, but you only need to use the tiniest amount. It spreads out a lot.”

    TikTok Shop review · 5★ · 2026-09-24

  • “A little goes a LONG way, so a jar lasts forever.”

    TikTok Shop review · 5★ · 2026-09-04

Pleasant scent options

3 of 71

Cited buyers enjoy the citrus and lavender scents as light and fresh.

“It has this bright, lemon‑pledge vibe but in the oddly addictive, “I actually want to wear this” way.”
Read 3 supporting reviews
  • “It has this bright, lemon‑pledge vibe but in the oddly addictive, “I actually want to wear this” way.”

    TikTok Shop review · 5★ · 2026-08-05

  • “I bought the citrus and it smells amazing”

    TikTok Shop review · 5★ · 2026-09-20

  • “The citrus scent is amazing—light, fresh and refreshing without being overpowering.”

    TikTok Shop review · 5★ · 2026-09-04

1 reviewer disagrees
  • “The smell is like plastic. No hints of lavender”

    TikTok Shop review · 1★ · 2026-03-20

Read low-star reviews

Counts use unique written five-star reviews in this report’s analyzed sample. One review can support several features. These are buyer experiences, not independent performance tests.

View listing details

Listing claims are separate from the review findings above and have not been independently verified.

Whipped beef tallow balm with Manuka honey, olive oil, and vitamin E for moisturizing, soothing, and softening dry or sensitive skin.

Brand
EVILGOODS
Skin care application time
Anytime
Additional features
Fast-absorbing
Specific uses for product
Dryness
Container type
Jar
Material type free
Ammonia free
Benefits
Hydrating,Smoothing,Nourishing,Softening,Smoothening,Cruelty free,Daily care,Damage repair,Moisturizing
Product benefits
Anti-aging
Benefit
Revitalizing,Soothing,Anti-aging,Moisturizing,Softening
Body part
Whole body,Back,Ft,Arms,Face,Body,Hand,Legs
Age group
Adults
Manufacturer
EVILGOODS
Feature
Natural,Fragrance free,Paraben free,Vitamin e,Phthalate free,Non toxic
SPF
0
Quantity per pack
1
Edition
Regular edition
Net weight
4oz
Contains alcohol or aerosol
Contains neither
Pack type
Single item
Shelf life
24 months
Region of origin
US
Product form
Balm
Skin type
All skin types
Dangerous goods or hazardous materials
No
Contains batteries or cells?
None
Flammable liquid
No
Aerosols
No
Ingredients
Vitamin e,Pot Marigold Extract,Beef Tallow,Manuka Honey,Olive Oil

Seller overview

evilgoods

TikTok Shop · Limited service data

evilgoods is the seller named in this TikTok Shop listing. The platform reports 56,555 followers and 17 listed products.

Delivery performance, customer support and refund handling have not been assessed. Store metrics alone do not establish seller reliability.

Before ordering

Confirm the delivery estimate and return eligibility with the seller before ordering.

Captured seller details
Followers
56,555
Listed products
17

Rating sample size and reporting period were not supplied.

Source: TikTok Shop listing · Captured 10/29/2026, 7:53:37 AM UTC

Compare prices

Amazon search results. Prices are shown for reference.

TikTok Shop listing

Seen 10/29/2026, 7:53:37 AM UTC · Shipping and tax unknown

$64.99 – $69.99

Amazon

$5.99

Whipped Beef Tallow & Honey Balm - 120g, Unscented Organic Face & Body Moisturizer, Grass-Fed, Nourishing Skin Lotion for Dry Skin, Lip Balm, Skin Care

Condition
Not confirmed
Shipping
Not confirmed
Tax
Not confirmed
Checked
Oct 29, 2026

Total checkout cost not confirmed

View on Amazon

Amazon

$18.99

Whipped Beef Tallow and Honey Balm, Beef Tallow Balm for Skin Care Tallow and Honey Cream, Grass Fed Grass Finished Face Cream, Natural Moisturizer for Face & Body(1PCS*120g)

Condition
Not confirmed
Shipping
Not confirmed
Tax
Not confirmed
Checked
Oct 29, 2026

Total checkout cost not confirmed

View on Amazon

Amazon

$13.99

JeurLrok Whipped Beef Tallow and Honey Balm,Beef Tallow for Skin,Tallow Face Moisturizer,Tallow and Honey Balm,Grass Fed Grass Finished Face Cream 2pcs

Condition
Not confirmed
Shipping
Not confirmed
Tax
Not confirmed
Checked
Oct 29, 2026

Total checkout cost not confirmed

View on Amazon

Searched Amazon · Oct 29, 2026 · View search results

Prices and availability can change; shipping, tax and price history are not confirmed.

If it doesn’t work out

TikTok Shop US gives eligible items a 30-day return window. This item’s eligibility is unconfirmed.

What reviewers said about returns

Insufficient data

Return and refund outcomes have not been assessed for this product.

There is not enough verified evidence to show refund counts, return reasons or resolution times.

Read captured reviews

Return terms

Eligible items: request a return within 30 days of delivery.

Return eligibility for this product has not been confirmed.

Most return methods are free. Follow the return instructions in the TikTok app.

Most refunds are issued 3–10 business days after the return is received and processed.

90-day Money-Back Guarantee for damaged or defective items.

Used, damaged or incomplete returns may incur a fee or reduced refund, unless caused by platform or seller error.

Source: TikTok Shop US return policy · checked

Platform policy only. Confirm item eligibility on the product page; submit return requests and track refunds in the TikTok app.

Reviewed alternatives

Finding reviewed alternatives…

Before you buy, ask the seller

How is the jar sealed for shipping, and what should I do if the seal arrives lifted or the jar is underfilled?
What is the expected fill level of the 4oz jar, and is a hollow in the balm normal?
Was this helpful?

Sources & scope

Description
TikTok Shop · Oct 29
Reviews
TikTok Shop · Oct 29
Prices
TikTok Shop, Amazon · Oct 29
Return rules
TikTok Shop, Amazon policies · Oct 29

Report date: Oct 29, 2026 · Missing: shipping and tax · item return eligibility